Primary sourceBook1871
An Examination of Mr. J. S. Mill's Philosophy
James McCosh · 1871
A critique of John Stuart Mill's philosophy by James McCosh, published in 1871 while Mill was still alive. It defends what McCosh calls fundamental truth.
This book is a contemporary critique of Mill's philosophy, written while he was alive and so showing how his ideas were received.
About this source
What it is
This is a book by James McCosh, professor of logic and metaphysics at Queen's College, Belfast. Its full title is An Examination of Mr. J. S. Mill's Philosophy: Being a Defence of Fundamental Truth. This copy is the second edition, with additions, published in New York by Robert Carter & Brothers in 1871. The preface quotes the French writer Alexis de Tocqueville on the connection between metaphysics and national character.
Why it matters
McCosh wrote while Mill was alive and active, so his book shows how a contemporary philosopher answered Mill's ideas. It places Mill within a debate among British and American thinkers about knowledge, the mind and morality. Reading a critic alongside Mill helps show what his opponents found convincing and what they rejected.
Look closer
- What does McCosh mean by 'fundamental truth', and what does he assume is at stake?
- Why does the author open with a quotation from another writer rather than from Mill?
- How would a reader who agreed with Mill respond to McCosh's arguments?
This book is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of John Stuart Mill on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More John Stuart Mill sources
Meet the AI John Stuart Mill →
BookPrimary source
On Liberty
John Stuart Mill · 1859
BookPrimary source
Utilitarianism
John Stuart Mill · 1861
BookPrimary source
The Subjection of Women
John Stuart Mill · 1869
BookPrimary source
Considerations on Representative Government
John Stuart Mill · 1861
Primary source
Autobiography
John Stuart Mill · 1873 (written; published posthumously)
Ready when you are
Start chatting with John Stuart Mill now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.