Skip to main content

Primary sourcePaintingFebruary 1926

And It Never Says a Mumblin' Word

J. Rogers · February 1926

A 1926 political cartoon in the Chicago Defender by J. Rogers. It shows President Coolidge as a silent sphinx while a lynching takes place beneath him.

Shows how a 1926 newspaper cartoon portrayed Coolidge as silent about lynching, which is why it sits in his archive.

Political cartoon titled 'And It Never Says a Mumblin' Word'. A caricature of President Calvin Coolidge's face is drawn on a sphinx-like stone figure labeled COOLIDGE. Below, a crowd gathers around a leafless tree from which a hanging figure dangles, while a cloud labeled 'Mob Rule in Enlightened Society' floats at left.
J. Rogers, And It Never Says a Mumblin' Word, The Chicago Defender, February 1926.

About this source

What it is

This political cartoon, titled And It Never Says a Mumblin' Word, appeared in the Chicago Defender in February 1926. The artist is J. Rogers. Coolidge is drawn as the Great Sphynx, a stone figure with his face and the name COOLIDGE on it. Below, a crowd gathers around a leafless tree with a hanging figure. A cloud labeled Mob Rule in Enlightened Society floats at the left. The image is a drawing from a 1926 print, and the description here comes from its Wikimedia Commons file page.

Why it matters

The cartoon criticises Coolidge for staying silent about lynching, the illegal killing of people by mobs. It is a primary source for the history of civil rights and of public opinion in the 1920s. Its artist used the familiar image of the sphinx to argue that a president who said nothing was still taking a side. The cartoon shows that ordinary readers and newspapers judged leaders by what they failed to say, not only by what they did.

Look closer

  • What do the stone face and the crowd show about who is watching and who is acting?
  • Why might the artist have chosen a sphinx, a figure linked with silence, instead of a speech or a letter?
  • What does the cartoon leave out, such as what Coolidge himself said or did about lynching?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Calvin Coolidge on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Calvin Coolidge now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.