Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting19 January 1881

Civil Service Reform, Compliments of R.B. Hayes

Frederick Burr Opper · 19 January 1881

A satirical 1881 Puck cartoon mocking Hayes's record on civil service reform as he left the presidency.

This cartoon mocks Hayes's civil service reform legacy as he departed the presidency, handing problems to Garfield.

Political cartoon in color. A bearded man in a green coat with red trim, labeled Garfield on a sign, stands with hand on chin looking down at a crying baby in a basket tagged Civil Service Reform, compliments of R.B. Hayes. A woman in a red shawl at left, carrying a bag labeled R.B. Hayes Savings Fremont Ohio, leans over an iron fence beside a street lamp and a building marked R.R. Ticket Office.
Frederick Burr Opper, Puck cartoon on civil service reform, 19 January 1881.

About this source

What it is

This cartoon by Frederick Burr Opper was published in Puck magazine on January 19, 1881, near the end of Hayes's presidency. It shows incoming President James Garfield looking at a crying baby in a basket labeled "civil service reform, compliments of R.B. Hayes," while Hayes, dressed as a woman, departs carrying a bag labeled with his savings and hometown.

Why it matters

The cartoon satirizes Hayes's attempts at civil service reform, suggesting his efforts left unfinished business for his successor Garfield. It shows how contemporaries judged the legacy of his presidency as he left office.

Look closer

  • Why might the cartoonist have chosen to depict civil service reform as an abandoned baby?
  • What does dressing Hayes as a woman suggest about how the cartoonist wanted viewers to see him?
  • What does this cartoon reveal about public opinion of Hayes's achievements at the end of his term?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Rutherford B. Hayes on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Rutherford B. Hayes now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.