Skip to main content

Primary sourceArtifact8 December 1913

Peace, Peace, There Is No Peace

Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew · 8 December 1913

A 1913 editorial cartoon showing Huerta with a pen before a document labelled Peace, while Carranza, Villa and Zapata appear nearby.

Places Villa among the rival revolutionary leaders around Huerta, as seen by an American newspaper cartoonist.

Editorial cartoon titled 'Peace, Peace, There Is No Peace.' A stern, heavyset man labelled Huerta in a striped suit holds a pen labelled Peace, looking at a document labelled Peace. A bearded man labelled Carranza in spectacles points at the document. In the background, figures labelled Zapata and Villa, wearing sombreros, approach with rifles. Palm trees stand at right. Caption reads 'From The Minneapolis Journal, Monday, Dec. 8, 1913.'
Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew, Peace, Peace, There Is No Peace, The Minneapolis Journal, 8 December 1913. Wikimedia Commons.

About this source

What it is

This is an editorial cartoon by Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew, titled 'Peace, Peace, There Is No Peace.' The printed caption credits The Minneapolis Journal of Monday, 8 December 1913. Mexican President Victoriano Huerta, a stern heavyset man, holds a pen labelled Peace and looks at a document labelled Peace. Carranza points at the document. In the background, Zapata and Villa, in sombreros, approach with rifles. Palm trees stand at the right. The Commons record notes that the curator dates it 1914, but the printed caption gives 1913.

Why it matters

The cartoon captures the confused state of the Mexican Revolution. Huerta, Carranza, Villa and Zapata were rival leaders, and rumours of a deal between Huerta and Carranza were in the news, which Carranza denied. The picture reflects how American readers followed these men as a crowd of competing forces, and how the question of whether peace was possible shaped US views of Mexico.

Look closer

  • Who is holding the pen, and why might the artist place the word Peace on both the pen and the document?
  • Why are Villa and Zapata shown in the background with rifles, and how does their position change the story?
  • What does the cartoon leave out about the people who suffered during the fighting?

This artifact is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Pancho Villa now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.