Skip to main content

Primary sourceArtifact30 December 1909

Plenty of Good Remedies, But They Don't Seem to Reach the Patient

Charles Lewis Bartholomew · 30 December 1909

A December 1909 political cartoon by Bart in the Minneapolis Journal showing Pinchot and Taft as doctors offering reform medicines to a sick consumer.

Shows Pinchot as one of several politicians offering reform remedies for high consumer prices in 1909.

Black and white editorial cartoon. A sick man labeled CONSUMER lies in a bed marked HIGH COST OF LIVING, out of reach of several politicians holding medicine bottles labeled with reform ideas such as Improved Farming, Anti-Futures Cotton, Conservation, Corporation Legislation, and Dr. Taft, Dr. Pinchot, Dr. Wilson, and Scott of Kansas. A sign reads U.S. National Sanitarium for the Cure of Commercial Ailments. Caption: Plenty of good remedies, but they don't seem to reach the patient. From The Minneapolis Journal, Thursday, Dec. 30, 1909.
Bart (Charles Lewis Bartholomew), Plenty of Good Remedies, But They Don't Seem to Reach the Patient, Minneapolis Journal, 30 December 1909.

About this source

What it is

This is a black-and-white editorial cartoon by Charles Lewis "Bart" Bartholomew, published in the Minneapolis Journal on Thursday, December 30, 1909. A sick man labeled CONSUMER lies in a bed marked HIGH COST OF LIVING, out of reach of several politicians holding medicine bottles. The bottles carry reform ideas such as Conservation and Corporation Legislation, and are labeled Dr. Taft, Dr. Pinchot, Dr. Wilson and Scott of Kansas. A sign reads U.S. National Sanitarium for the Cure of Commercial Ailments.

Why it matters

The cartoon uses a sickroom metaphor to comment on the rising prices of consumer goods in 1909. It shows President Taft and Pinchot as leaders offering reform remedies, and it suggests that these reforms did not reach ordinary people. It reveals how contemporary observers judged the political debate of the time.

Look closer

  • Who is shown as the patient, and what does the bed label tell you about the problem?
  • Why might the cartoonist have chosen doctors and medicine bottles to represent politicians?
  • What does the cartoon leave out about whether the reforms actually worked?

This artifact is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Gifford Pinchot on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Gifford Pinchot now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.