Skip to main content

Primary sourceDocument2005

Roper v. Simmons Dissent

Sandra Day O'Connor · 2005

Justice O'Connor's dissenting opinion in the 2005 case that banned the death penalty for crimes committed under age 18.

Her dissent shows her distinct, evidence-focused reasoning on the juvenile death penalty.

Full text (Wikisource)

About this source

What it is

This is Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's dissenting opinion in Roper v. Simmons (2005), in which the Supreme Court ruled 5–4 that executing offenders for crimes committed before age 18 is unconstitutional, overturning its earlier decision in Stanford v. Kentucky.

Why it matters

O'Connor disagreed with the majority, arguing the evidence did not clearly show a national consensus against executing 17-year-olds and that the Court's ruling rested on its own moral judgment rather than settled law. The case shows her careful, evidence-based reasoning and her willingness to dissent even on a major moral and legal question, as other justices like Anthony Kennedy wrote the majority view.

Look closer

  • Why might O'Connor have disagreed with the majority despite the case's moral weight?
  • What kind of evidence does she say is missing to support the ruling?
  • What does a dissent reveal about disagreement within the Supreme Court?

This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Sandra Day O'Connor on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Sandra Day O'Connor now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.