Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting23 November 1872

Schurz Defeat of Liberal Republicans

Thomas Nast · 23 November 1872

A Thomas Nast cartoon from 1872 showing Carl Schurz among defeated Greeley supporters after the presidential election.

Shows Schurz among defeated Liberal Republicans after backing Greeley's losing campaign against Grant.

Engraved cartoon titled 'The Insult Returned' by Thomas Nast. A heap of men in suits and hats lies collapsed before a standing woman in a flowing gown, who is at right by a gate and a dome-topped building. Signs on a wall read Cincinnati Convention, Baltimore Convention, and Horace Greeley. Labels on the ground read Spite, Envy, Malice, Slander, and Misrepresentations. Caption below reads 'Men and Brethren! The Cincinnati Convention has proved a Fiasco, and it did not name the Next President.'
Thomas Nast, 'The Insult Returned', 1872.

About this source

What it is

This 1872 engraving by Thomas Nast, titled "The Insult Returned," shows Carl Schurz and other supporters of the Greeley-Brown ticket collapsed in a heap before Columbia, a female figure representing the United States. In the background, Uncle Sam celebrates alongside the victorious candidate Ulysses S. Grant.

Why it matters

Schurz had broken from the Republican Party to support Horace Greeley's failed 1872 presidential bid against Grant. This cartoon mocks that defeat, showing Schurz and his allies—including August Belmont, Reuben Fenton, and Lyman Trumbull—as humiliated losers, reflecting Nast's strong support for Grant.

Look closer

  • What does the pose of the defeated men suggest about how Nast wanted viewers to see them?
  • Why might Nast have chosen symbolic figures like Columbia and Uncle Sam instead of showing the election itself?
  • What does this cartoon reveal about the cartoonist's own political loyalties?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Carl Schurz on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Carl Schurz now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.