Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting18 December 1869

Sliding on Thin Ice: Pius IX and the First Vatican Council

John Tenniel · 18 December 1869

A satirical Punch cartoon by John Tenniel from 1869, showing Pius IX leading clergy across cracking ice during the First Vatican Council.

Pius IX is caricatured as the leading figure guiding bishops toward danger during the Vatican Council he convoked.

Black and white engraved cartoon. A line of robed clergy in tall mitres and hoods walks single file along a path toward a crack in the ice, led by a stout man in a large ornate headdress. A sign reads DANGEROUS. On the left, top-hatted men in frock coats watch from the bank.
John Tenniel, 'Sliding on Thin Ice: Pius IX and the First Vatican Council', Punch, 18 December 1869. Wellcome Collection.

About this source

What it is

This wood-engraved cartoon by John Tenniel appeared in the British magazine Punch on 18 December 1869. It shows a line of clergy in tall mitres walking across a plank laid on ice, led by a stout figure in an ornate headdress, toward a crack marked "dangerous", while top-hatted onlookers watch from the bank. It is held by the Wellcome Collection.

Why it matters

The cartoon satirises Pius IX leading the bishops of the First Vatican Council, which that same year was moving toward declaring papal infallibility. British cartoonists like Tenniel often mocked the Catholic Church's claims to authority, and this image shows how controversial and risky contemporaries viewed the council's direction.

Look closer

  • Who do you think the figure leading the group represents, and how is he drawn differently from the others?
  • Why might the cartoonist show the group walking toward a sign reading "dangerous"?
  • What point of view does this cartoon take, and whose opinion might it not represent?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Pope Pius IX on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Pope Pius IX now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.