Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting30 April 1884

Spoiling Their Calculations

Joseph Keppler · 30 April 1884

A 1884 Puck cartoon showing President Arthur and James G. Blaine at a table of convention papers, with an 'Independent Voter' deciding the Republican Party's fate.

Arthur appears as a rival candidate for the 1884 Republican nomination, shown as subject to the power of the independent voter.

Full page from the April 30, 1884 issue of Puck magazine, with its masthead and a color cartoon titled 'Spoiling Their Calculations' by Joseph Keppler. Three men sit and stand at a table; a standing man in a top hat and blue coat points at papers marked for the Republican State Convention at Utica, N.Y. Signs in the background read 'for C.A. Arthur' and 'for J.G. Blaine'.
Joseph Keppler, Spoiling Their Calculations, Puck, April 30, 1884.

About this source

What it is

This is a chromolithograph cartoon by Joseph Keppler, published on the cover of Puck magazine on April 30, 1884. It shows James G. Blaine and Chester A. Arthur seated at a table covered with papers about the 1884 Republican State Convention in Utica, New York. A man labeled 'Independent Voter' stands between them, marking an X on Blaine's paper and about to do the same to Arthur's.

Why it matters

Arthur and Blaine were rivals for the 1884 Republican presidential nomination. Puck, a satirical magazine, used cartoons like this to comment on political maneuvering and to suggest that ordinary voters, not party insiders, held real power over the outcome. Whitelaw Reid, a newspaper editor, also appears in the scene.

Look closer

  • Why does the cartoonist give the 'Independent Voter' the most power in this scene?
  • What does the setting of a convention tell you about how presidential candidates were chosen in this era?
  • What is left out of this image that a photograph of the real convention might show?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Chester A. Arthur on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Chester A. Arthur now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.