Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting17 August 1872

Sumner at Brooks's Grave Cartoon

Thomas Nast · 17 August 1872

A Thomas Nast cartoon from 1872 shows Charles Sumner placing flowers on the grave of his old attacker Preston Brooks, with Carl Schurz watching from behind a tree.

Schurz appears watching Sumner in this cartoon commenting on reconciliation politics during the 1872 Liberal Republican split.

Engraved political cartoon. A man in a dark suit kneels at a tombstone inscribed 'In Memory of Bully Brooks, Member of Congress from South Carolina, who caned the Senator from Mass., May 22 1856, died 1857', placing flowers on the grave. A small figure in a top hat peers from behind a tree. Papers in a hat at the bottom read in part 'Sumner's Letter'. Caption below reads 'Will the Senator from Massachusetts do this, to make his words good?'
Thomas Nast, cartoon of Sumner at Brooks's grave with Schurz behind a tree, Harper's Weekly, 17 August 1872.

About this source

What it is

This engraved cartoon by Thomas Nast appeared in Harper's Weekly on 17 August 1872. It shows Senator Charles Sumner kneeling at the grave of 'Bully Brooks', the congressman who had once caned him, while Carl Schurz watches from behind a tree. The caption quotes a letter from Sumner calling for reconciliation.

Why it matters

The cartoon comments on calls for sectional peace after the Civil War, questioning whether Sumner's words of forgiveness matched his actions. Schurz's presence in the background shows he was seen as a watchful political ally or rival observing Sumner's conduct during the 1872 Liberal Republican controversy.

Look closer

  • Why does Nast place Schurz hiding behind a tree rather than standing openly?
  • What does the tombstone's wording tell you about how Brooks was remembered?
  • How does the quoted letter change the meaning of the image?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Carl Schurz on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Carl Schurz now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.