Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting1896

The Bad Man Referee

New York Herald · 1896

A newspaper caricature of Wyatt Earp published after he refereed the controversial 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight.

This cartoon mocks Earp personally after he refereed a controversial 1896 boxing match, showing his damaged public reputation.

Ink cartoon titled The Bad Man Referee. A large caricatured figure in a huge sombrero-like hat, with a mustache, holds a revolver in one hand and a money bag labeled $10,000 in the other, with a knife clenched in his teeth. Two small boxers labeled Fitz and Tom sit and stand at either side.
The Bad Man Referee, New York Herald, 1896.

About this source

What it is

This is an ink cartoon published by the New York Herald, showing a large caricatured figure in a huge hat holding a revolver and a money bag, with a knife clenched in his teeth. Two small boxers labeled Fitz and Tom appear beside him. It was made after the 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match.

Why it matters

Wyatt Earp acted as referee in the fight and ruled in favor of Sharkey, even though Fitzsimmons appeared to be winning, because of a foul. The public was outraged, and newspapers mocked Earp for weeks. This cartoon shows how far his reputation had shifted from frontier lawman to a figure of public ridicule, revealing how the press shaped and distorted his public image.

Look closer

  • What details in the drawing make Earp look dangerous or dishonest?
  • Why might a newspaper want to exaggerate a public figure's faults?
  • What does this cartoon leave out about why Earp made his decision?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Wyatt Earp on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Wyatt Earp now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.