Primary sourcePainting1896
The Bad Man Referee
New York Herald · 1896
A newspaper caricature of Wyatt Earp published after he refereed the controversial 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight.
This cartoon mocks Earp personally after he refereed a controversial 1896 boxing match, showing his damaged public reputation.

About this source
What it is
This is an ink cartoon published by the New York Herald, showing a large caricatured figure in a huge hat holding a revolver and a money bag, with a knife clenched in his teeth. Two small boxers labeled Fitz and Tom appear beside him. It was made after the 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match.
Why it matters
Wyatt Earp acted as referee in the fight and ruled in favor of Sharkey, even though Fitzsimmons appeared to be winning, because of a foul. The public was outraged, and newspapers mocked Earp for weeks. This cartoon shows how far his reputation had shifted from frontier lawman to a figure of public ridicule, revealing how the press shaped and distorted his public image.
Look closer
- What details in the drawing make Earp look dangerous or dishonest?
- Why might a newspaper want to exaggerate a public figure's faults?
- What does this cartoon leave out about why Earp made his decision?
This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Wyatt Earp on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Wyatt Earp sources
Browse all 58 →Primary source
Wyatt Earp's Statement at the Spicer Hearing
Wyatt Earp · 16 November 1881
Primary source
Yesterday's Tragedy: Tombstone Epitaph Report on the Gunfight
Tombstone Epitaph (John Clum, editor) · 27 October 1881
PaintingPrimary source
Wyatt Earp Lithograph
PhotographPrimary source
Dodge City Peace Commission
Conkling Studio · early June 1883
Free account
Read every Wyatt Earp source
Sign up free →
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Wyatt Earp now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.


