Primary sourceBook1904
The Bordereau: Study of the Bertillon and Valerio Testimony
1904
A 1904 pamphlet of 63 pages by an anonymous former student of the Ecole polytechnique. It examines the handwriting testimony given against Dreyfus at the Rennes court-martial.
Shows how the handwriting evidence used against Dreyfus at Rennes was publicly examined and challenged.
Free Humy account · No credit card · 120,912 sources to read
About this source
What it is
This 1904 pamphlet is titled Le Bordereau: étude des dépositions de M. Bertillon et du Capitaine Valerio au Conseil de Guerre de Rennes. The author is listed only as an former student of the Ecole polytechnique. It was printed in Paris by Hardy and Bernard, and the record lists 63 pages, with plates sold separately for 5 francs. The bordereau is the note at the centre of the case, and the cover quotes an old maxim of criminal law about proving the body of the crime.
Why it matters
The handwriting evidence was a key part of the case against Dreyfus. At the Rennes court-martial, M. Bertillon and Captain Valerio gave testimony about the handwriting, and this pamphlet examines what they said. The Internet Archive record also lists Esterhazy, the man many later readers linked to the note, which shows how closely the handwriting dispute was tied to his name. The pamphlet shows that the evidence itself was being contested in public.
Look closer
- What does the epigraph suggest the author thinks the court must prove?
- Why would an anonymous author hide his name, and how does that affect how much we can trust the argument?
- What would a handwriting expert have needed to show to convince readers either way?
This book is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Alfred Dreyfus on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Alfred Dreyfus sources
Browse all 98 →
Newspaper articlePrimary source
J'accuse…!
Émile Zola · 13 January 1898
PaintingPrimary source
The Degradation of Alfred Dreyfus
Henri Meyer
Primary source
Cinq Années de ma vie
Alfred Dreyfus · 1901
LetterPrimary source
Lettres d'un innocent
Alfred Dreyfus · 1894–1898 (published 1898)
Free account
Read every Alfred Dreyfus source
Sign up free →
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Alfred Dreyfus now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.



