Primary sourcePainting11 April 1904
The Real Bone
Bob Satterfield · 11 April 1904
A 1904 Bob Satterfield editorial cartoon about a railway dispute involving J. P. Morgan's interests. Two bulldogs fight over the Northern Pacific Railway while a bystander looks on.
Shows Morgan's financial interests in the Northern Pacific Railway dispute of 1904, placing him among the bulldogs in the cartoon.

About this source
What it is
This is a 1904 editorial cartoon by Bob Satterfield, dated 11 April 1904, titled The Real Bone. Two bulldogs labeled Harriman Interests and Hill-Morgan Interests growl at each other over a bone labeled Northern Pacific R.R. A man with glasses sits on a fence in the middle, captioned The Party on the Fence, and watches and points. A small figure at right says Wish there was a tree round here! A sign labeled Decision Against Northern Securities Co. lies at lower right. The cartoon is signed Satterfield, N.E.A.
Why it matters
The cartoon shows a fight over control of the Northern Pacific Railway. It places Morgan together with James J. Hill in the bulldog labeled Hill-Morgan Interests, and places E. H. Harriman in the rival bulldog. The sign about the Northern Securities Company refers to a court decision, which points to the legal struggles that surrounded these railway and financial interests. Cartoons like this one turned complicated business rivalries into simple pictures that ordinary readers could understand at a glance.
Look closer
- Why does the artist use bulldogs and a bone to stand for railway companies and their owners?
- Who is the man on the fence, and what does his position suggest about the artist's view of the dispute?
- What details of the actual railway business are missing from a cartoon like this, and how might that change a reader's understanding?
This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of J.P. Morgan and James J. Hill on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More J.P. Morgan sources
Meet the AI J.P. Morgan →
DocumentPrimary source
Testimony of J. P. Morgan before the Pujo Committee
U.S. House Committee on Banking and Currency (Pujo Committee) · 18 December 1912
PhotographPrimary source
Photographic Portrait of J. Pierpont Morgan
Edward Steichen
DocumentPrimary source
Sherman Anti-Trust Act
2 July 1890
DocumentPrimary source
Pujo Report
U.S. House Committee on Banking and Currency · 28 February 1913
ArtifactPrimary source
The Morgan Library & Museum
Charles McKim (McKim, Mead & White) · 1902–1906, opened to the public 1924
Ready when you are
Start chatting with J.P. Morgan now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.