Primary sourcePainting1871
The Ring Arithmetic
Thomas Kelly and William C. Robertson · 1871
An 1871 satirical lithograph attacking the Tweed Ring's corruption, the type of municipal graft Steffens later investigated.
Illustrates the Tweed Ring corruption that foreshadowed the municipal graft Steffens later exposed.

About this source
What it is
This is an 1871 lithograph print titled 'The Ring Arithmetic, as Taught by the Modern Ceasers.' It satirizes Tammany boss William Marcy Tweed and New York City comptroller Richard B. Connolly, showing Tweed teaching Connolly fraudulent 'arithmetic' about city debts and inflated bills for building projects.
Why it matters
This cartoon exposes the financial corruption of Tweed's Ring, which drained millions from New York City's treasury. It represents the same tradition of exposing political and financial corruption that Lincoln Steffens continued decades later in his own investigative journalism.
Look closer
- What does the chalkboard's false math suggest about how corruption was hidden in plain numbers?
- Why do the artists use a classroom setting to mock the Ring's dishonesty?
- How does this cartoon's message connect to the kind of exposés Steffens later wrote?
This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Lincoln Steffens on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Lincoln Steffens sources
Meet the AI Lincoln Steffens →
BookPrimary source
The Shame of the Cities
Lincoln Steffens · 1904
PhotographPrimary source
Portrait of Lincoln Steffens
Primary source
Upbuilders, Chapter 4: Rudolph Spreckels, a Business Reformer
Lincoln Steffens · 1909
PhotographPrimary source
Linc. Steffens
Bain News Service
Primary source
The Shame of Minneapolis, McClure's Magazine, January 1903
Lincoln Steffens · January 1903
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Lincoln Steffens now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.