Skip to main content

Primary sourcePaintingApril 1843

Trouble in the Spartan Ranks

C. Maolsehber · April 1843

An 1843 anti-Dorrite satirical cartoon depicting Thomas Wilson Dorr with horns and a cloven hoof atop Governor James Fenner.

This anti-Dorrite cartoon caricatures Dorr himself as a devilish figure, showing how opponents portrayed him.

Satirical lithograph titled 'Trouble in the Spartan Ranks, Old Durham in the Field,' with a 'Second Edition' header. A line of top-hatted men marches toward a castle-like arsenal with banners, while a knight in armor carries a banner of an eagle and a figure in a stout coat with horns is shown at right. Dense text captions fill the bottom.
C. Maolsehber, Trouble in the Spartan Ranks, April 1843.

About this source

What it is

This satirical lithograph, made in April 1843 by C. Maolsehber, is titled "Trouble in the Spartan Ranks, Old Durham in the Field." It shows a line of Dorrite supporters marching toward an arsenal, with Governor James Fenner depicted as a stout man with horns, and Thomas Wilson Dorr shown above him as a devil-like figure with a cloven hoof.

Why it matters

Created during the Dorr Rebellion, this cartoon reveals how Dorr's opponents viewed him — as a dangerous, almost demonic troublemaker threatening the established government. The print also contains racist caricature imagery, showing how political cartoons of this period mixed serious political commentary with demeaning stereotypes.

Look closer

  • Why do you think the cartoonist chose to depict Dorr as a devil-like figure?
  • What does the inclusion of racist caricature tell us about attitudes among Dorr's opponents at the time?
  • How can a satirical image like this be useful to historians even though it is not a neutral record?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thomas Wilson Dorr on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Thomas Wilson Dorr now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.