Skip to main content

Primary sourceLetter1861

Two Open Letters to Spaeth and Scanzoni

Ignaz Semmelweis · 1861

Printed 1861 open letters by Semmelweis to obstetrics professors Spaeth and Scanzoni, documenting his escalating public polemic.

These letters, written by Semmelweis, show his direct public campaign naming specific opponents of his handwashing theory.

Cover of a green paperback pamphlet in Gothic black-letter type titled 'Zwei offene Briefe an Dr. J. Spaeth, Professor der Geburtshilfe an der k. k. Josefs-Akademie in Wien, und an Hofrath Dr. F. W. Scanzoni, Professor der Geburtshilfe zu Würzburg, von Dr. J. Ph. Semmelweis.' Imprint reads Pest, Gustav Emich, 1861. A library stamp and label are in the corners.
Ignaz Semmelweis, Zwei offene Briefe an Dr. J. Spaeth und an Hofrath Dr. F. W. Scanzoni, Pest, 1861.

About this source

What it is

This is a printed pamphlet of two open letters written by Ignaz Semmelweis in 1861, addressed to Dr. J. Spaeth, professor of obstetrics in Vienna, and Hofrath Dr. F. W. Scanzoni, professor of obstetrics in Würzburg. It was printed in Pest by Gustav Emich in 1861, in Gothic type, with footnotes.

Why it matters

The letters show Semmelweis publicly accusing named leading obstetricians, including Prof. Eduard Martin of Berlin, of ignorance about the cause of childbed fever. This source documents how far his dispute with the medical establishment had escalated by 1861, and how he used print to call out specific, powerful opponents by name rather than argue quietly within the profession.

Look closer

  • What does naming specific professors suggest about Semmelweis's strategy for changing medical opinion?
  • Why might this confrontational approach have helped or hurt the acceptance of his ideas?
  • What does the source not tell us about how Spaeth, Scanzoni or Martin reacted?

This letter is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Ignaz Semmelweis on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Ignaz Semmelweis now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.