Skip to main content

Primary sourcePhotographc. 1848–1853

Unauthenticated Portrait Said to Show Emily Dickinson

Unknown · c. 1848–1853

A disputed cabinet card photograph, copied from an older daguerreotype, that some have claimed shows a young Emily Dickinson, though scholars disagree.

This photograph is sometimes claimed, without firm proof, to depict Emily Dickinson as a young woman.

Sepia-toned portrait of a woman with dark hair pulled back, wearing a dark dress with a white collar and bow, seated in an ornate carved chair with her hands resting on a table edge.
Cabinet card copy of an unauthenticated daguerreotype said to show Emily Dickinson, c. 1848–1853. Identification disputed by scholars.

About this source

What it is

This cabinet card is a later copy of a daguerreotype taken around 1848 to 1853, showing a seated woman in a dark dress. Some have suggested the sitter is a young Emily Dickinson, but the photographer is unknown and the identification is not certain.

Why it matters

Only one confirmed photograph of Emily Dickinson is known to exist, so claims about other portraits attract attention and debate. According to Dickinson scholar George Gleason, experts have agreed that a mere belief that the sitter resembles the young Dickinson is not enough evidence to prove her identity. This image is a useful case study in how historians weigh evidence before accepting a claim.

Look closer

  • What details in the photograph might make someone think this is Dickinson, and what details make it uncertain?
  • Why do scholars require more than a resemblance to confirm a historical photograph's subject?
  • What problems can arise when images are used in history without solid proof?

This photograph is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Emily Dickinson on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Emily Dickinson now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.