Skip to main content

Primary sourceArtifact

Which Pipe?

Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew

A black-and-white 1900-era cartoon by Bart showing Kruger and John Bull offering rival peace pipes, each with different conditions.

A cartoon that presents Kruger as a negotiator whose peace terms clash with Britain's, during the Boer War.

Black-and-white ink cartoon titled 'Which Pipe?'. On the left, a stern bearded man in a tall top hat labeled 'OOM PAUL' holds out a pipe labeled 'Pipe of Peace'. On the right, a plump man in a top hat labeled 'JOHN BULL' smokes a cigar and offers a long pipe labeled 'Peace Pipe'. Smoke above reads 'British Conditions'; a bag near them reads 'Boer Conditions'. Caption below reads 'If They Could but Agree on This, There Would Soon Be a Smoking of the Pipe of Peace.'
Bart, Which Pipe?, black-and-white ink cartoon. Commons record.

About this source

What it is

This black-and-white ink cartoon by Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew is titled Which Pipe?. A bearded man labeled 'OOM PAUL' holds out a pipe labeled 'Pipe of Peace'. Across from him, a plump man labeled 'JOHN BULL' smokes a cigar and offers a long pipe labeled 'Peace Pipe'. Smoke above reads 'British Conditions', and a bag reads 'Boer Conditions'. The caption reads: 'If They Could but Agree on This, There Would Soon Be a Smoking of the Pipe of Peace.'

Why it matters

During the Boer War, both sides talked about peace while keeping their own terms. The cartoon shows that the two leaders, Kruger for the Boers and John Bull for Britain, wanted peace on different conditions. It reflects how newspapers and cartoonists in Britain and elsewhere followed the war and its negotiations, and it shows how each side's demands made agreement difficult.

Look closer

  • What is the difference between the two pipes, and what do the smoke labels tell you?
  • Why might the cartoonist show each leader holding a different object?
  • What does the caption suggest would have to happen before peace could come?

This artifact is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Paul Kruger on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Paul Kruger now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.