Skip to main content

Primary sourceSpeech4 December 1849

Argument of Charles Sumner against the Constitutionality of Separate Colored Schools

Charles Sumner · 4 December 1849

Sumner's 1849 legal argument in the Roberts v. City of Boston case, challenging school segregation and coining the phrase 'equality before the law.'

Sumner personally argued this case against school segregation, decades before similar arguments succeeded nationally.

Title page of a printed legal argument: 'Argument of Charles Sumner, Esq., against the Constitutionality of Separate Colored Schools, in the case of Sarah C. Roberts vs. The City of Boston, before the Supreme Court of Mass., Dec 4, 1849.' Imprint reads Boston: Published by B. F. Roberts, 1849; Printed at No. 5 Cornhill.
Charles Sumner, Argument against the Constitutionality of Separate Colored Schools, 4 December 1849. Massachusetts Historical Society.

About this source

What it is

This printed pamphlet contains the legal argument made by Charles Sumner, with Robert Morris, before the Supreme Court of Massachusetts on 4 December 1849. The case, Roberts v. City of Boston, was brought on behalf of five-year-old Sarah C. Roberts, who had been refused entry into a public school because of her race.

Why it matters

Sumner argued that separating children by race in public schools violated the state constitution, introducing the phrase 'equality before the law.' Although the court ruled against Roberts, the argument became an important early challenge to segregation and is seen as an ancestor of the reasoning used a century later in Brown v. Board of Education.

Look closer

  • Why do you think Sumner chose to argue this case even though he expected to lose?
  • What does the case tell us about how segregation worked in the North, not just the South?
  • How might this argument have influenced later civil rights cases?

This speech is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Charles Sumner on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Charles Sumner now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.