Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting1856

Southern Chivalry – Argument versus Club's

John L. Magee · 1856

A political cartoon showing Preston Brooks caning Charles Sumner in the Senate chamber, used by Northern abolitionists as anti-slavery propaganda.

This cartoon depicts the caning of Sumner, the violent attack that followed his anti-slavery speech.

Black-and-white lithograph cartoon of a man in a long coat swinging a heavy cane at a seated man who is slumped on the floor, with a crowd of onlookers in the background and papers on a desk. Title text is printed below.
John L. Magee, Southern Chivalry – Argument versus Club's, 1856. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division.

About this source

What it is

This lithograph was created by John L. Magee in 1856. It depicts Representative Preston Brooks attacking Senator Charles Sumner with a cane inside the Senate chamber, an event that followed Sumner's 'Crime Against Kansas' speech.

Why it matters

The image became a famous piece of Northern political propaganda, expressing outrage that the South had turned from argument to violence. It shows how the caning of Sumner was used to rally anti-slavery sentiment and deepen sectional hatred in the years before the Civil War.

Look closer

  • What choices did the artist make to make the viewer sympathize with Sumner?
  • Why would Northern newspapers want to spread an image like this?
  • What does the title 'Argument versus Clubs' suggest about how the artist saw the two sides of the slavery debate?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Charles Sumner on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Charles Sumner now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.