Skip to main content

Primary sourcePaintingSeptember 1890

Judge Cartoon on McKinley's Gerrymandered District

Victor Gillam · September 1890

An 1890 magazine cover cartoon showing McKinley and Speaker Thomas Reed fleeing after McKinley's congressional district was redrawn and he lost his seat.

This cartoon depicts McKinley's congressional district being redrawn, leading to the loss of his House seat in 1890.

Colored cartoon of two caricatured men in exaggerated costumes hurrying along a road. The man in front wears armor, a plumed helmet and carries a spear and axe; he is labeled McKinley. The man behind wears a plumed hat and ruffled Renaissance-style dress, carrying a bag with a tiger-like head; he is labeled Tom Reed. Signposts read 'To McKinley's Jerrymandered District' and 'Reed Elected by a Tremendous Majority'.
Victor Gillam, Judge magazine cover, September 1890. McKinley Presidential Library, Canton, Ohio.

About this source

What it is

This is the cover of Judge magazine from September 1890, drawn by Victor Gillam. It shows Speaker Thomas B. Reed of Maine and William McKinley, then chair of the Ways and Means Committee, depicted as costumed figures fleeing along a road, referring to the redrawing of McKinley's Ohio district and his loss of his seat.

Why it matters

This cartoon reflects the political tariff battles of the late 1880s and 1890s, when McKinley was a leading figure in tariff policy in Congress. It also shows how cartoonists used costume and caricature to comment on congressional politics and alliances between McKinley and Reed.

Look closer

  • Why are McKinley and Reed shown in costumes rather than ordinary clothes?
  • What does the cartoon suggest about the relationship between the two men?
  • What historical event does the signpost text refer to, and why would readers in 1890 have understood it?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of William McKinley on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with William McKinley now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.