Skip to main content

Secondary sourceSpeech1886

L'Orangisme et le catholicisme: Sir George E. Cartier Le Grand Chef du Bas-Canada contre Sir John A. Macdonald

Joseph-Hyacinthe Bellerose · 1886

A partisan 1886 pamphlet by Joseph-Hyacinthe Bellerose praising Cartier as leader of Lower Canadians against Macdonald.

This 1886 pamphlet uses Cartier's memory as a political symbol in a dispute between French Catholics and Macdonald's supporters.

L'Orangisme et le catholicisme: Sir George E. Cartier Le Grand Chef du Bas-Canada contre Sir John A. MacdonaldPDF · 26 pages
Joseph-Hyacinthe Bellerose, L'Orangisme et le catholicisme, 1886. Scanned book, Internet Archive.

About this source

What it is

This is a printed pamphlet from 1886 containing a speech by Joseph-Hyacinthe Bellerose, delivered in the Senate on 2 March 1886. It presents George-Étienne Cartier as the great leader of Lower Canada, contrasted with John A. Macdonald, whom the author accuses of being hostile to Catholics and French Canadians.

Why it matters

Published more than a decade after Cartier's death, this pamphlet shows how he was remembered and used in later political and religious debates between English and French Canadians, and between Catholics and Protestants. It reveals how Cartier's legacy was shaped by later generations for their own political arguments, including comparisons with his former ally Macdonald.

Look closer

  • Why might Bellerose want to praise Cartier while attacking Macdonald, years after both were gone from power?
  • What does the title tell you about the religious and political tensions in Canada at this time?
  • How reliable is a partisan speech like this as a source about Cartier's actual beliefs and actions?

This speech is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of George-Étienne Cartier on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with George-Étienne Cartier now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.