Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting22 September 1900

McKinley Destroys Imperialism Straw Man

William Allen Rogers · 22 September 1900

A 1900 political cartoon by William Allen Rogers showing McKinley blasting apart a straw figure labeled 'Imperialism' with a cannon representing his public letter.

This cartoon depicts McKinley defending his expansionist policies against critics of American imperialism.

Political cartoon by William Allen Rogers. A cannon labeled McKinley's Letter, fired from a cliff by a man near a drawing of the White House, blasts apart a large straw-stuffed figure with a crown reading Imperialism, sending debris flying. Figures tumble in the explosion, including a man holding a sword and a man with a banner reading Anti-Imperialism. Signed T.W.A. Rogers at lower left.
William Allen Rogers, 'Smashed!', 1900. Scanned image.

About this source

What it is

This cartoon was drawn by William Allen Rogers and published on 22 September 1900. It shows a cannon labeled "McKinley's Letter" destroying a straw-stuffed figure wearing a crown marked "Imperialism."

Figures tumble from the blast, representing critics of American expansion, including Carl Schurz, William Lloyd Garrison (likely a relative or namesake critic), and Richard Olney.

Why it matters

The cartoon is a response to the fierce debate in the United States over imperialism after the Spanish-American War, when the country took control of territories like the Philippines. It shows how McKinley's supporters depicted anti-imperialist arguments as exaggerated or false — a "straw man" — using a public letter from the president as a weapon against his critics.

Look closer

  • Why does the cartoonist show imperialism's critics as a straw man rather than real opponents?
  • What does the cartoon suggest about how McKinley's own words were used in political debate?
  • Whose side does this cartoon take, and how can you tell?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of William McKinley on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with William McKinley now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.