Secondary sourceDocumentary6 October 2018
Parkar: The Prophet of Islam, can our sources be trusted?
BBC Persian · 6 October 2018
A 2018 Persian-language BBC documentary that asks how reliable the historical sources for Muhammad's life are, and how far they are mixed with legend.
A modern programme about how far the sources for Muhammad's life can be trusted, useful for studying how his history is known.
Free Humy account · No credit card · 120,912 sources to read
About this source
What it is
This is a video documentary in Persian, made by BBC Persian and dated 6 October 2018. Its description asks what is known about the historical Muhammad, how much of it is mixed with legend, and how far his main sources can be trusted. It is a modern programme, not a document from Muhammad's time.
The description says that one of the oldest non-Islamic records of his life reports, two years after his death, that a religious leader had appeared among the Arabs, as reported in Byzantium. It names the main Muslim sources as hadith, the Qur'an and archaeological finds. The guests are listed as Armin Ashrafi, a professor of religious studies, and Zakaria Mashkoor Kabuli, a researcher of Islamic studies. The description also cites Harald Motzki, a researcher of hadith, who says that critical use of hadith would make writing a biography of the Prophet much harder.
Why it matters
Students of the Prophet's life work with sources of very different ages and kinds, and this programme shows how scholars weigh them. It is a modern summary of a debate, so it is a secondary source: its views belong to its presenters and guests, not to people of the seventh century. It shows how scholars disagree about how much early texts can reveal about Muhammad.
Look closer
- Which sources does the programme name as the main ones for knowing Muhammad, and which of them were written during his lifetime?
- Why might a Byzantine record from two years after his death be treated as valuable, and what would a historian still need to check?
- Who speaks in this programme, and how might their own views shape the questions they ask?
This documentary is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Muhammad on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Muhammad sources
Browse all 71 →
BookPrimary source
Qur'an
compiled 632-656 (this manuscript 12th century)
DocumentPrimary source
Birmingham Quran Manuscript
568–645 CE
BookPrimary source
Sana'a Manuscript
c. 650 CE
BookSecondary source
Sahih al-Bukhari
Muhammad ibn Isma'il al-Bukhari · c. 846 CE
Free account
Read every Muhammad source
Sign up free →
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Muhammad now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.


