Skip to main content

Primary sourceDocument1863

Reply of Lieut.-Col. Pilsen to Emil Schalk's Criticisms of Frémont's Campaign

John Pilsen · 1863

A June 1863 printed reply by John Pilsen to Emil Schalk's criticisms of Frémont's 1862 mountain department campaign, written during the Civil War.

This reply defends Frémont's 1862 mountain department campaign against published criticism, showing how his military record was argued during the Civil War.

Free Humy account · No credit card · 121,771 sources to read

John Pilsen, Reply of Lieut.-Col. Pilsen to Emil Schalk's Criticisms of the Campaign in the Mountain Department, June 1863. Bancroft Library; Internet Archive scan.

About this source

What it is

This is a 14-page printed reply written by John Pilsen, a lieutenant colonel, and dated York, June 1863. It answers Emil Schalk, author of the book Summary of the Art of War, who criticized the campaign of Major General J. C. Frémont in the mountain department. The pamphlet is addressed to Schalk as a letter and argues that a history must be checked carefully before it is published. The Bancroft Library holds a copy, and the Internet Archive holds a scan.

Why it matters

Schalk's second volume discussed the campaigns of 1862 and 1863, and Pilsen defended the reputations of living commanders whose honor, he wrote, was tied to the nation's well-being. The debate shows how Civil War campaigns were judged in print while the war was still going on.

Look closer

  • What standard of truth does Pilsen say a historian must meet, and does he meet it himself?
  • Why would a military campaign be debated in a printed pamphlet rather than in official reports?
  • Whose side is the author on, and what evidence does he give for his judgment?

This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of John C. Frémont on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with John C. Frémont now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.