Skip to main content

Primary sourcePhotograph1937

Senate Judiciary Committee considers Roosevelt's Supreme Court plan, 1937

Harris & Ewing · 1937

A 1937 news photograph of senators meeting over President Roosevelt's request to enlarge the Supreme Court, the debate Black faced when he joined the Court.

This news photograph documents the 1937 Court-packing debate that was the background to Black joining the Court.

Black-and-white photograph of about ten men in suits gathered around a conference table. Two seated men sign or review papers in the foreground, while standing men look on. Framed portraits hang on the wall behind them.
Harris & Ewing, Senate Judiciary Committee considers president's request to increase membership of Supreme Court, Washington D.C., 1937.

About this source

What it is

This is a 1937 news photograph by Harris & Ewing, taken in Washington D.C. Its caption says that after a meeting, members of the Senate Judiciary Committee reported that opinion in their group was about evenly divided on President Roosevelt's request for power to increase the membership of the Supreme Court, possibly to 15 members. The image shows about ten men in suits around a conference table, with two seated men reviewing papers and standing men looking on. Framed portraits hang on the wall behind them.

Why it matters

The photograph shows the political fight over the Court in 1937, often called the Court-packing debate. Black was a new justice who faced this debate as he joined the Court. The record names the senators pictured, including William E. Borah, Henry F. Hurst, and Pat McCarran, so students can trace who was involved. The picture reveals how the public saw Congress and the Court in that year.

Look closer

  • Who is seated and who is standing, and what might their positions tell you?
  • What does the caption say about the committee's opinion, and how sure is it?
  • What does a single news photograph leave out about the debate itself?

This photograph is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Hugo Black on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Hugo Black now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.