Skip to main content

Primary sourcePhotograph1917

Smashed Up German Trench on Messines Ridge with Dead

John Warwick Brooke · 1917

An official 1917 battlefield photograph from Haig's own album, showing a destroyed German trench strewn with dead soldiers after the Messines attack.

From Haig's own album of official photographs, showing the battlefield his 1917 Messines offensive produced.

Black-and-white photo of a shattered trench with torn-up earth, broken wooden planks and woven wattle revetment. Several dead soldiers in uniform lie tangled among the debris in the foreground.
John Warwick Brooke, Smashed up German trench on Messines Ridge with dead, 1917. From Haig's 'Official Photographs' album.

About this source

What it is

A black-and-white photograph taken by official photographer John Warwick Brooke, from the series of official photographs kept in Haig's own album. It shows a shattered German trench on Messines Ridge, with the bodies of dead German soldiers among the wreckage.

Why it matters

This image, from the Western Front in 1917, documents the destructive reality of trench warfare that Haig directed as commander-in-chief. Because it comes from Haig's personal album of official photographs, it shows what he himself saw and kept as a record of operations such as the Messines attack, raising questions about how commanders viewed and recorded the human cost of their campaigns.

Look closer

  • Why might an official photograph like this have been taken and preserved?
  • What does the original caption tell you about how the army described such scenes?
  • What does the photograph not tell you about the people who died there?

This photograph is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Field Marshal Douglas Haig on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Field Marshal Douglas Haig now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.