Skip to main content

Secondary sourcePainting1857

Socrates Rebuking Alcibiades in a Courtesan's House

Germán Hernández Amores · 1857

An 1857 painting by Germán Hernández Amores showing Socrates rebuking Alcibiades in a courtesan's house. It is a later artist's imagined scene from the Athenian statesman's youth.

Shows Socrates rebuking Alcibiades in a courtesan's house as a later painter imagined it, reflecting how his teacher's criticism was remembered.

Painting of a classical interior with a woman wearing a laurel wreath and red drape seated on a couch, a young man with a laurel wreath reclining on a stool, and a bearded older man in a green-gold cloak gesturing toward him. A white statue of Eros stands on a pedestal labeled EROS, and a doorway opens onto a colonnaded view.
Germán Hernández Amores, Socrates Rebuking Alcibiades in a Courtesan's House, 1857.

About this source

What it is

This is an 1857 painting by Germán Hernández Amores. It shows a classical interior with a woman in a laurel wreath and red drape seated on a couch, and a young man in a laurel wreath reclining on a stool. A bearded older man in a green-gold cloak gestures toward him. A white statue of Eros stands on a pedestal labeled EROS, and a doorway opens onto a colonnaded view. The Commons record describes it as Socrates rebuking Alcibiades in a courtesan's house.

Why it matters

Alcibiades was a student of the philosopher Socrates, and this painting presents a moment when the teacher criticizes him for his company. Hernández Amores painted the scene in the 19th century, so it shows how later artists understood the relationship between the two men. The painting is an imagined scene and tells us about 19th-century views of ancient Athens.

Look closer

  • What does the statue of Eros suggest about the mood of the room?
  • How does the older man's gesture show what the painter wants us to think of Alcibiades?
  • What does this painting leave out about the real relationship between Socrates and Alcibiades?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Alcibiades on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Alcibiades now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.