Primary sourcePainting1871
The Ring Arithmetic
Thomas Kelly and William C. Robertson · 1871
An 1871 lithograph caricaturing the Tweed Ring's corrupt bookkeeping, showing a teacher-like figure confronting a boss over inflated city bills.
This lithograph satirizes the fraudulent billing practices of the Tweed Ring that Tweed led in New York City.

About this source
What it is
This is a lithograph print from 1871, created by Thomas Kelly and William C. Robertson, titled The Ring Arithmetic — As Taught by the Modern Ceasers. It shows a large, heavyset bearded man pointing at a smaller man standing at a blackboard covered with inflated bills for items like plasterers, upholsterers, plumbers, and safes, with a city debt ledger nearby.
Why it matters
The cartoon satirizes the inflated and fraudulent bills run up by the Tweed Ring, the group of corrupt officials around William Tweed who controlled New York City's government and treasury. Prints like this circulated widely and helped the public understand, in a simple visual way, how the Ring's padded invoices drained the city's finances.
Look closer
- What do the labeled bills on the blackboard suggest about how the Ring stole money?
- Why might the artists have chosen a classroom scene to explain financial fraud?
- Who do you think the large bearded figure and the small figure on the stool are meant to represent?
This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of William M. Tweed on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More William M. Tweed sources
Browse all 69 →
PaintingPrimary source
The Brains
Thomas Nast · 21 October 1871
ArtifactSecondary source
Tweed Courthouse
John Kellum · 1872
PhotographPrimary source
William M. (Boss) Tweed, N.Y
Mathew Benjamin Brady
PhotographPrimary source
William Magear Tweed Portrait, Facing Left
Free account
Read every William M. Tweed source
Sign up free →
Ready when you are
Start chatting with William M. Tweed now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.


