Skip to main content

Primary sourceBookMay 1921

The Scale of the Universe

Harlow Shapley · May 1921

A 1921 National Research Council bulletin by astronomer Harlow Shapley, with a second part by Heber D. Curtis, on how large the Milky Way is and the nebula debate about the universe's size.

Shapley's 1921 account of the nebula debate that Hubble later resolved; it is context for his work, not a text by or about Hubble.

The Scale of the UniversePDF · 52 pages
Harlow Shapley and Heber D. Curtis, The Scale of the Universe, National Research Council Bulletin, 1921. Scanned PDF, Internet Archive.

About this source

What it is

This is a printed bulletin of the National Research Council, Volume 2, Part 3, Number 11, dated May 1921. Part I is by Harlow Shapley of the Mount Wilson Observatory, Carnegie Institution of Washington. Part II is by Heber D. Curtis, Director of the Allegheny Observatory. The copy here is a scanned PDF from the Internet Archive, reprinted for Harvard University's natural sciences course. The text covers the history of ideas about the size of the galaxy, surveys of the solar neighborhood, globular clusters, and the spiral nebulae.

Why it matters

In 1921 astronomers argued over whether spiral nebulae were parts of our own galaxy or separate galaxies far outside it. Shapley and Curtis presented opposing views of that question in this bulletin. Edwin Hubble later resolved the debate with observations of stars in these nebulae. The text does not mention Hubble, so it shows the problem he would later solve rather than his work. It reveals how scientists of the time used measurements of stars and clusters to estimate distances.

Look closer

  • What does Shapley describe as the size of the galaxy, and how sure does he sound about his measurements?
  • Why do the two authors each write their own part, and where do they seem to disagree?
  • What questions about the universe does this text leave unanswered?

This book is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Edwin Hubble on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Edwin Hubble now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.