Skip to main content

Secondary sourcePaintingcirca 1630

Two Old Men Disputing (St. Peter and St. Paul)

Circle of Jan Lievens (formerly attributed to Rembrandt) · circa 1630

A dim 1630-era painting of two elderly men in debate, once thought to be by Rembrandt and now linked to the circle of Jan Lievens. It is titled as a scene of Saint Peter and Saint Paul.

Shows Saint Peter in a debate scene with Paul, so it appears in Peter's archive as a later image of him rather than a work from his lifetime.

Painting of two elderly men in a dim interior. A bearded man in a green robe leans over a table with an open book and stacked volumes, facing forward. A second older man with a red cap sits on a wooden chair in dark robes, seen from behind and to the side. A draped grey-green tablecloth hangs over the table edge.
Circle of Jan Lievens (formerly attributed to Rembrandt), Two Old Men Disputing (“St. Peter and St. Paul”), circa 1630.

About this source

What it is

This is a painting titled Two Old Men Disputing, also known as “St. Peter and St. Paul.” It shows a bearded man in a green robe leaning over a table with an open book and stacked volumes, and a second older man in a red cap and dark robes seated on a wooden chair. The painting is dated to around 1630. It was formerly attributed to Rembrandt. Later it was seen as a copy from the 18th century, and it is now attributed to the circle around Jan Lievens.

Why it matters

The painting is one of many images in which Saint Peter appears in a scene of debate and study. Its title links it to Peter and his fellow apostle Paul, but the image itself does not carry a name or inscription in the facts we have. Its shifting attribution shows how historians rely on style, workshop, and date to decide who painted a work and when.

Look closer

  • What do the two men seem to be doing, and how does the book on the table suggest their purpose?
  • Why might a painter place one figure facing us and the other turned away?
  • Since the title names Peter and Paul, what details would help you decide whether the painting truly shows them, and what does it leave out?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Saint Peter on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Saint Peter now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.