Skip to main content

Primary sourcePhotograph2008

What it Means to Be Human Panel, World Science Festival 2008

Markus Pössel · 2008

A photograph of Marvin Minsky on a panel discussing human nature at the 2008 World Science Festival.

This photograph documents Minsky's participation in a major public discussion on human nature late in his career.

Twelve people seated in red-orange chairs on a stage, in front of large projected silhouettes of adults and children holding hands. The panel is seated in a row, with a small table of water glasses in front of them.
Markus Pössel, Panel discussion "What it Means to Be Human," World Science Festival, 2008.

About this source

What it is

This photograph, taken by Markus Pössel, shows a panel discussion titled "What it Means to Be Human" at the 2008 World Science Festival. Marvin Minsky is seated among a row of scientists and scholars including Paul Nurse, Ian Tattersall, Daniel Dennett, Francis Collins, Patricia Churchland, and Antonio Damasio, with Charlie Rose moderating.

Why it matters

The panel brought together leading thinkers from biology, genetics, philosophy, and cognitive science to debate questions about human identity and consciousness. Minsky's presence shows his standing late in life as a figure whose work on the mind and artificial intelligence was seen as central to big questions about what makes us human.

Look closer

  • Why might organizers gather scientists from such different fields to talk about one question?
  • What does the staging and the projected images behind the panel suggest about the event's purpose?
  • What might be missing from a short photograph of a long discussion?

This photograph is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Marvin Minsky on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Marvin Minsky now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.