Primary sourceBook1808
A Plea for Religion and the Sacred Writings
David Simpson · 1808
A book by the Reverend David Simpson, first published in 1808 and addressed to Thomas Paine's disciples and wavering Christians. It answers Paine's deism from a Christian viewpoint.
A Christian reply written for Paine's followers, showing how contemporaries argued against the deism Paine promoted in his own lifetime.

About this source
What it is
This is a book by the Reverend David Simpson, minister of Christ Church in Macclesfield. The title page says it is addressed to the disciples of Thomas Paine and to wavering Christians of every persuasion. It explains the author's decision to give up his post in the established church and the reasons for that decision. The edition shown is a fifth edition printed in London in 1808. The copy here is a scanned book from the Internet Archive.
Why it matters
Paine's deism was the target of this book, and it shows how a churchman answered Paine's ideas while Paine was still alive. Simpson wrote for readers who had been drawn to Paine's views, so the book reveals the religious debate of the early 1800s from the Christian side.
Look closer
- Who does the author say he is writing for, and how might that shape his arguments?
- Why might a minister publicly explain his reasons for leaving his church?
- Which views of Paine and his followers does the book not describe fairly, or leave unanswered?
This book is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thomas Paine on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Thomas Paine sources
Meet the AI Thomas Paine →
BookPrimary source
Common Sense
Thomas Paine · 10 January 1776
BookPrimary source
The American Crisis
Thomas Paine · 1776-1783
BookPrimary source
Rights of Man
Thomas Paine · 1791-1792
BookPrimary source
The Age of Reason
Thomas Paine · 1794-1807
DocumentPrimary source
Declaration of Independence
Continental Congress (drafted by Thomas Jefferson) · 1776
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Thomas Paine now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.