Skip to main content

Primary sourceNewspaper article1890

Canadian Protection Compared with the McKinley Tariff, Reply to Macdonald

Joseph Nimmo Jr. · 1890

An 1890 newspaper reply by Joseph Nimmo Jr. to a speech by Macdonald at Halifax, arguing about Canadian protectionist tariffs and the McKinley Tariff Act.

A contemporary rebuttal of a Macdonald speech on protectionist tariff policy, showing how his tariff positions were challenged in public.

Canadian Protection Compared with the McKinley Tariff, Reply to MacdonaldPDF · 8 pages
Joseph Nimmo Jr., Canadian Protection Compared with the Provisions of the McKinley Tariff Act, 1890. Scanned pamphlet, Internet Archive.

About this source

What it is

This is a reply printed in the New York Tribune on October 24, 1890, by Joseph Nimmo Jr. and later reprinted as a pamphlet. It answers a speech Macdonald gave at Halifax against the McKinley tariff bill. Nimmo argues that Macdonald's Conservative party came to power in 1878 on a protectionist platform, so his criticism of protection is inconsistent. The surviving copy is a scanned pamphlet.

Why it matters

The text shows the dispute between Canadian and American trade policy in 1890. It records how a critic in the United States read Macdonald's speech and how he used Macdonald's own party history against him. It shows that tariff policy was a sharp political issue on both sides of the border.

Look closer

  • Nimmo writes in a mocking style. How does his tone affect the way a reader judges Macdonald?
  • The pamphlet answers a speech Macdonald gave to a Halifax audience. What does Nimmo leave out of his account of that speech?
  • Why might a newspaper in New York have printed a reply about Canadian tariffs?

This newspaper article is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Sir John A. Macdonald on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Sir John A. Macdonald now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.