Skip to main content

Primary sourceDocument1991

Harmelin v. Michigan

Thurgood Marshall · 1991

A 1991 dissent by Justice Thurgood Marshall that agrees with Justice White on proportionality and restates his view that capital punishment is always unconstitutional.

Shows Marshall's opposition to harsh punishment, including his position that capital punishment is always unconstitutional.

Source: Wikisource

About this source

What it is

This is a dissenting opinion written by Justice Thurgood Marshall in Harmelin v. Michigan, decided in 1991 and reported at 501 U.S. 957. The case concerned a life sentence without parole for drug possession. Marshall says he agrees with Justice White's dissent, except where White says the Eighth Amendment does not prohibit the death penalty. The text is preserved on Wikisource.

Why it matters

Marshall restates his long-held view that capital punishment is unconstitutional in all instances. He also argues that the Eighth Amendment requires comparative proportionality review of death sentences, because of the uniqueness of the death penalty. His opinion shows how he tied his opposition to harsh punishment to earlier cases such as Gregg v. Georgia. It reveals the sharp divisions among the justices over how the Eighth Amendment limits punishment.

Look closer

  • Why does Marshall say that the death penalty is treated differently under the Eighth Amendment?
  • How does Marshall use earlier opinions and cases to support his position?
  • What does this dissent leave out about the drug offense and the defendant's own circumstances?

This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thurgood Marshall on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Thurgood Marshall now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.