Skip to main content

Primary sourceDocument1991

In Re Amendment to Rule 39 (Marshall dissent)

Thurgood Marshall · 1991

Justice Thurgood Marshall's dissent, joined by Justices Blackmun and Stevens, objecting to the Court's order barring an indigent litigant from filing in forma pauperis petitions for extraordinary writs.

Marshall wrote this dissent himself, showing his opposition to the Court limiting the filing rights of poor litigants.

Source: Wikisource

About this source

What it is

This is a written dissent by Justice Thurgood Marshall in the 1991 Supreme Court decision In re Amendment to Rule 39, reported as 500 U.S. 13. Marshall wrote it with Justices Blackmun and Stevens. The text is listed on Wikisource, and the copy here is a transcribed version of the opinion rather than the printed reporter page.

Why it matters

The Court had barred John Demos from filing future cases without paying fees, and Marshall argued that the Court had not identified any statute or rule giving it power to impose such a permanent ban. He pointed to two earlier cases, In re Sindram and In re McDonald, as part of a pattern. The dissent shows how Marshall protected the access of poor people to the courts.

Look closer

  • What reasons does Marshall give for saying the Court acted without clear authority?
  • Why does he say paying litigants often commit the same fault, and what does that comparison suggest?
  • What does the dissent leave out about Demos's own filings and the reasons the Court gave?

This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thurgood Marshall on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Thurgood Marshall now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.