Primary sourceLetter6 September 1819
Letter from Thomas Jefferson to Spencer Roane
Thomas Jefferson · 6 September 1819
A letter in which Jefferson attacks the judiciary's growing power, a direct response to the doctrine established in Marbury's case.
Jefferson's later attack on judicial power responds to the doctrine the Supreme Court asserted in Marbury's own case.
About this source
What it is
This is a letter written by Thomas Jefferson to Judge Spencer Roane on 6 September 1819. It is held in the Thomas Jefferson Papers at the Library of Congress.
Why it matters
In the letter Jefferson complains that the Constitution has become, in his words, 'a mere thing of wax in the hands of the judiciary.' This was a direct criticism of the Marshall Court's claim to judicial review, the power the Supreme Court asserted when it decided William Marbury's lawsuit. The letter shows how controversial that ruling remained years later among Jefferson and his allies.
Look closer
- Why would Jefferson, a former president, object so strongly to judicial power?
- What does the wax metaphor suggest about how Jefferson saw the Constitution being reshaped?
- Whose perspective is missing from this private letter?
This letter is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of William Marbury on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More William Marbury sources
Meet the AI William Marbury →Primary source
Jefferson's First Inaugural Address
Thomas Jefferson · 4 March 1801
DocumentPrimary source
Marbury v. Madison
1803
PaintingPrimary source
William Marbury
James Peale · c. 1790s
DocumentPrimary source
Federal Judiciary Act
United States Congress · 24 September 1789
DocumentPrimary source
Alien and Sedition Acts
Fifth Congress of the United States · 1798
Ready when you are
Start chatting with William Marbury now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.