Skip to main content

Primary sourceDocument1 June 1971

Nelson v. O'Neil dissent

Thurgood Marshall · 1 June 1971

A dissent by Justice Thurgood Marshall in the 1971 Supreme Court case Nelson v. O'Neil, arguing that joint trials can harm defendants' rights.

Shows Marshall as a Supreme Court justice writing a dissent that argues for new rules on joint criminal trials.

Source: Wikisource

About this source

What it is

This is a dissent written by Justice Thurgood Marshall in Nelson v. O'Neil, a case of the United States Supreme Court. The case was argued on March 24, 1971 and decided on June 1, 1971. The text is the court's printed report, as held by the Wikisource record.

Marshall writes that the case shows the need for new rules on joint trials, in which several defendants are tried together. He says that a statement by one defendant was not admissible against the other under state law, yet there was a real danger it was used against him.

Why it matters

The dissent shows how a joint trial could affect each defendant's rights, including the right of confrontation and equal protection. Marshall cites his colleague Justice Brennan and the earlier case Bruton v. United States. He also refers to a recommendation from the American Bar Association's advisory committee on the criminal trial. The text reveals how a justice used a losing opinion to push for change in legal practice.

Look closer

  • Which rights does Marshall say are put at risk in a joint trial?
  • Why might a dissent matter even when it does not change the outcome of a case?
  • What does this text leave out about the defendants and what really happened at their trial?

This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thurgood Marshall on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Thurgood Marshall now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.