Primary sourceDocument1991
Payne v. Tennessee
Thurgood Marshall · 1991
A 1991 Supreme Court case allowing victim impact statements in death penalty sentencing; Marshall's dissent, among his last, warned that 'power, not reason' now guided the Court.
This was one of Marshall's final dissents, written the day he announced his retirement, criticizing the Court's reversal of precedent.
About this source
What it is
This is the Supreme Court's 1991 decision in Payne v. Tennessee, which held that victim impact statements could be used during death penalty sentencing, overturning two earlier precedents. It includes the dissenting opinion written by Justice Thurgood Marshall, joined by Justice Blackmun.
The case arose from a Tennessee murder conviction and considered whether allowing such statements violated the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment.
Why it matters
Chief Justice Rehnquist's majority opinion reversed precedents set only a few years earlier, something Marshall's dissent condemned as driven by changes in the Court's membership rather than legal reasoning. Written on the day Marshall announced his retirement, the dissent is often read as a summary statement of his view of the Court's direction near the end of his career.
Look closer
- Why did Marshall argue that overturning recent precedents was especially troubling here?
- What does the timing of this dissent, on the day of his retirement announcement, suggest about its tone?
- How does this case show disagreement over how much respect the Court should give to its own past decisions?
This document is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Thurgood Marshall on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Thurgood Marshall sources
Meet the AI Thurgood Marshall →
DocumentPrimary source
Brown v. Board of Education
Earl Warren · 17 May 1954
PaintingPrimary source
Thurgood Marshall
Betsy Graves Reyneau · 1956
PhotographPrimary source
George Edward Chalmer Hayes, Thurgood Marshall, and James Nabrit in 1954 winning Brown case
1954
PhotographPrimary source
Thurgood Marshall and President Lyndon B. Johnson, June 13, 1967
Frank Wolfe · 13 June 1967
Primary source
Cooper v. Aaron
12 September 1958
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Thurgood Marshall now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.