Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting16 January 1907

Ships That Pass In the Night

Charles Lewis Bartholomew · 16 January 1907

A 1907 political cartoon criticizing James J. Hill and other wealthy men for receiving large government ship subsidies meant for independent shipowners.

Satirizes Hill as one of the wealthy men benefiting unfairly from a ship subsidy bill meant for independent shipowners.

Political cartoon titled 'Ships That Pass In the Night.' A chalkboard sign reads 'Subsidy Soup.' Three heavyset men in top hats labeled Spreckels, Hill, and Harriman stand in line at a counter. A bald, smiling man in an apron labeled Congress hands out sandwiches; signs read Harriman $700,000, Spreckels $200,000, and Hill $700,000. Caption below quotes the question about whether ship subsidy reaches needy independent owners. Dated Wednesday, Jan. 16, 1907, from The Minneapolis Journal.
Charles Lewis Bartholomew, 'Ships That Pass In the Night,' The Minneapolis Journal, 16 January 1907.

About this source

What it is

This cartoon, titled 'Ships That Pass In the Night,' was drawn by Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew and published in The Minneapolis Journal on January 16, 1907. It shows three wealthy men labeled Harriman, Hill, and Spreckels receiving large sums of money labeled as subsidies from a figure labeled Congress, while a sign reads 'Subsidy Soup.'

Why it matters

The cartoon satirizes a congressional ship subsidy bill meant to help independent shipowners, but which critics said mainly benefited already wealthy businessmen like Hill, Edward Harriman, and Claus Spreckels. It shows how Hill, despite his fame as a railroad builder, was also publicly criticized for using political influence for personal gain.

Look closer

  • Why did the cartoonist choose to show the men as 'fat' and receiving sandwiches labeled with dollar amounts?
  • What point is the caption's question making about who benefits from the subsidy bill?
  • What does this cartoon leave out about the actual subsidy legislation?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of James J. Hill on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with James J. Hill now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.