Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting28 February 1907

Some Tough Morsels For the Whale

Charles Lewis Bartholomew · 28 February 1907

A 1907 cartoon showing Jim Hill and other magnates thrown overboard from a ship as Congress revised the ship subsidy bill.

Depicts Jim Hill being thrown overboard, symbolizing his exclusion from the revised ship subsidy bill's benefits.

Black-and-white ink cartoon titled 'Some Tough Morsels for the Whale.' A giant whale labeled 'Ship Subsidy' swims beside a sailing ship whose crew watches. Figures labeled Harriman, Spreckels, and others are thrown into the sea. A caption below reads 'Throwing Overboard the Jonahs from Ship Subsidy' and 'From The Minneapolis Journal, Thursday, Feb. 28, 1907.'
Charles Lewis Bartholomew, 'Some Tough Morsels for the Whale,' The Minneapolis Journal, 28 February 1907.

About this source

What it is

This ink cartoon, titled 'Some Tough Morsels for the Whale,' was drawn by Charles Lewis 'Bart' Bartholomew and published in The Minneapolis Journal on February 28, 1907. It shows a giant whale labeled 'Ship Subsidy' beside a ship, with figures labeled Harriman, Spreckels, and Jim Hill being thrown into the sea.

Why it matters

The cartoon marks a moment when the Ship Subsidy Bill was changed so that money would no longer go to railroad trusts, meaning men like Jim Hill, Edward Harriman, and Claus Spreckels lost out. It shows how public and political pressure could push back against powerful railroad men even at the height of their influence.

Look closer

  • Why are Hill and the others shown being thrown overboard rather than receiving money, as in the earlier cartoon?
  • What does the whale labeled 'Ship Subsidy' represent?
  • What does the cartoon's title, referencing 'Jonahs,' suggest about how the cartoonist viewed these men?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of James J. Hill on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with James J. Hill now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.