Skip to main content

Primary sourceArtifactSunday, Jan. 20, 1907

The Railroads a Timid Creature

Charles Lewis Bartholomew · Sunday, Jan. 20, 1907

A two-panel cartoon contrasting Hill's claim that railroads were harmless with the public's view of them as dangerous.

Depicts Hill's argument that railroads were harmless, against public fears of railroad power.

Two-panel newspaper cartoon titled 'The Railroads a Timid Creature'. Left panel: a man in a hat and suspenders says 'Such a timid creature!' while a man in a suit and a figure labeled 'The Public' stand near a tree; a small creature labeled 'The Timid Railroad' crouches beside the tree. Right panel: the same creature, labeled 'The Timid Railroad', charges at a man in a suit who is flying through the air, and a small dog-like figure flees. Captions below read 'As Seen by Jim Hill' and 'And as It Strikes the Public', with a date of Sunday, Jan. 20, 1907.
Charles Lewis Bartholomew, The Railroads a Timid Creature, 20 January 1907.

About this source

What it is

This two-panel newspaper cartoon, drawn by Charles Lewis Bartholomew and dated Sunday, Jan. 20, 1907, contrasts two views of railroads. In the first panel, labeled 'As Seen by Jim Hill', a small creature called 'The Timid Railroad' cowers from the public and lawmakers. In the second, labeled 'And as It Strikes the Public', the same creature charges aggressively at a man representing the public.

Why it matters

The cartoon illustrates a real argument of the time: Hill and other railroad owners insisted regulation was unnecessary because railroads posed no threat, while much of the public feared the growing power of railroad companies. It shows how cartoonists used contrast to question business leaders' claims.

Look closer

  • Why does the cartoonist draw the same creature two different ways?
  • What does this suggest about trust between the public and railroad owners like Hill?
  • Whose side does the cartoonist seem to favor, and how can you tell?

This artifact is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of James J. Hill on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with James J. Hill now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.