Skip to main content

Primary sourceNewspaper articleMarch 1930

Time magazine review of Mountain City

March 1930

A March 1930 Time magazine book review of Upton Sinclair's novel Mountain City. The critic judges Sinclair a poor novelist whose political message overwhelms his storytelling.

This 1930 review judges Sinclair as a novelist and shows how a contemporary critic saw his politics and fiction.

Full text (Wikisource)

About this source

What it is

This is a book review from Time magazine, published in March 1930 under the heading Sinclairity. It reviews Mountain City by Upton Sinclair, published by A. & C. Boni at $2.50. The text is available on Wikisource.

The reviewer argues that Sinclair might be a better novelist if he kept his anti-capitalist propaganda out of his books. The review calls him the foremost believer in Art for Man's Sake among American authors, and describes him as preacher first and novelist second, a bad second. It summarises the novel's story of Jed Rusher, a farmer's boy who rises to wealth and power.

Why it matters

A contemporary review shows how a critic in 1930 judged Sinclair's fiction. The reviewer's dislike of his politics shapes the judgement, which is useful for students to compare with how Sinclair's readers and later historians saw his work. The review also shows the public debate over the role of social protest in American novels of that time.

Look closer

  • Which words show the reviewer's opinion of Sinclair, and which describe the novel itself?
  • Does the reviewer give evidence for the claim that the propaganda is the problem?
  • What might a reader who shared Sinclair's politics have thought of this review?

This newspaper article is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Upton Sinclair on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Upton Sinclair now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.