Secondary sourceBook1887
Whether Eratosthenes Rightly Judged Odysseus' Wanderings
Maximilianus Hergt · 1887
An 1887 school study examining how Eratosthenes judged the geography of Odysseus' wanderings in Homer's Odyssey.
This study analyzes Eratosthenes' critical judgment of the geography described in Homer's Odyssey.
Free Humy account · No credit card · 120,912 sources to read
About this source
What it is
This is a school programme (an academic essay published by a German secondary school) written by Maximilianus Hergt in 1887 for the Landshut school in Bavaria. It examines Eratosthenes' views on the geography described in Homer's Odyssey.
Why it matters
Eratosthenes was known for criticizing attempts to pin down the exact real-world locations of Odysseus' travels, arguing that Homer's poem was not a reliable geography. This later study shows how scholars continued to debate and test his reasoning centuries afterward, and how his critical approach to myth and geography influenced later scholarship.
Look closer
- Why might a mathematician and geographer like Eratosthenes have cared about judging a poem like the Odyssey?
- What does it suggest about Eratosthenes' thinking that he doubted the poem could be used as a real map?
- Why would a school in 1887 choose to study an ancient scholar's opinion about an even older poem?
This book is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Eratosthenes on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.
More Eratosthenes sources
Browse all 52 →
BookSecondary source
Geography
Strabo · c. 20 AD
LetterPrimary source
The Method of Mechanical Theorems
Archimedes · c. 250 BCE
DocumentSecondary source
Suda
various authors · c. 1000
Secondary source
Natural History, Book 2, on Eratosthenes' Earth Measurement
Pliny the Elder · c. 77 CE
Free account
Read every Eratosthenes source
Sign up free →
Ready when you are
Start chatting with Eratosthenes now.
20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.



