Skip to main content

Primary sourcePainting1602

Saint Matthew and the Angel

Caravaggio · 1602

Caravaggio's rejected first version of an altarpiece for the Contarelli Chapel, destroyed in Berlin in 1945 and now known only from photographs.

Caravaggio's rejected first version of the Matthew altarpiece, revealing the realist style his patrons found too crude.

Black and white photograph of a painting: a bald, bearded older man in dark robes sits writing in a open book on his knee, while a winged angel with curly hair leans over his shoulder pointing at the page. Dark background.
Caravaggio, Saint Matthew and the Angel, 1602 (destroyed 1945), known from a pre-war photograph.

About this source

What it is

This painting was completed by Caravaggio in 1602 for the Contarelli Chapel in Rome. It showed Saint Matthew, depicted as an unlearned, poorly groomed peasant with dirty feet, being guided by a swooping angel as he wrote the Gospel. The original work was later destroyed by fire in Berlin at the end of World War II and survives only through black-and-white photographs.

Why it matters

The church and Caravaggio's patron, Cardinal del Monte, rejected this painting as too crude and irreverent for a sacred altarpiece, and Caravaggio had to paint a replacement, The Inspiration of Saint Matthew. The rejection reveals the tension between Caravaggio's realist style, which favoured ordinary, unidealized figures, and the decorum expected by religious patrons of the time.

Look closer

  • Why do you think the church found this image of Saint Matthew disrespectful?
  • What does it mean to study a painting only from old black-and-white photographs?
  • How does comparing this rejected version with the accepted one help us understand what patrons valued?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Caravaggio on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Caravaggio now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.