Skip to main content

Secondary sourcePainting1882

Reason against unreason

Joseph Keppler · 1882

An 1882 Puck magazine cartoon by Joseph Keppler placing Spinoza among history's champions of reason against superstition and bigotry.

This 1882 cartoon places Spinoza among history's icons of reason, showing his later image as a hero of free thought.

Colored print from the Puck magazine titled 'Reason Against Unreason'. Upper left inset shows robed figures presenting a baby with the caption 'God Made Man and Endowed Him with Free Will, Memory and Understanding.' Right side shows bust portraits in a beam labeled 'Light of Reason.' Lower left, a crowd sheltering under a large umbrella labeled 'Supernaturalism' and 'Fetish' is pushed up a hill. Lower right inset shows a cleric hammering a boy at a desk, captioned 'But if You Took a Dose of Alkaline in the Man before He Could be Made a Good Citizen'.
Joseph Keppler, 'Reason against unreason,' Puck magazine, 8 March 1882.

About this source

What it is

This is a chromolithograph print by cartoonist Joseph Keppler, published as a centerfold in Puck magazine in 1882. It shows a beam called the "Light of Reason" containing bust portraits of thinkers including Kepler, Kant, Thomas Paine, Jefferson, Spinoza, Franklin, Voltaire, Haeckel, Tyndall, Huxley, and Darwin, shining against a crowd sheltering under an umbrella labelled "Bigotry, Supernaturalism, and Fanaticism," behind which clergy figures including the Pope are hidden.

Why it matters

This cartoon reveals how, two centuries after his death, Spinoza had become a symbol of free thought and rationalism in the popular imagination, grouped together with scientists, philosophers, and political figures seen as opponents of religious dogma. It shows how his ideas were used in later debates about reason, science, and religion.

Look closer

  • Why do you think the artist chose to place Spinoza alongside figures like Darwin and Voltaire?
  • What does the imagery of clergy hiding under an umbrella suggest about the cartoonist's own views?
  • Whose voices or viewpoints are missing from this picture of the debate over reason and religion?

This painting is part of the curated material that grounds the AI version of Baruch Spinoza on Humy.ai — when students ask about related events, the AI can quote it and cite it.

Ready when you are

Start chatting with Baruch Spinoza now.

20 messages free · No credit card · Available in 50+ languages.